Brenden Snedeker said Trump gets the credit. Most outlets buried that.
The US won its 11th straight Presidents Cup on Sunday at Medinah, coming back from a deficit to beat the International team in singles. That's the wire version. The more interesting version is that US captain Brenden Snedeker publicly credited Donald Trump — who gave a speech before the final day — and the Guardian was the only outlet in this group that put that quote in its headline. The NY Post found a different story entirely, and it was a good one.
US retains Presidents Cup with dramatic comeback
4 sources · hover a dot to see coverage
What happened
The United States defeated the International team at Medinah Country Club on Sunday to win an 11th consecutive Presidents Cup title. The US trailed heading into the final-day singles session and rallied to close out the match. US captain Brenden Snedeker, in post-match remarks, said Trump 'gets all the credit,' referencing a speech Trump gave to the American team before Sunday's singles. Scottie Scheffler, the world's top-ranked player, was involved in a notable moment on the 14th hole when a spectator heckled International team member Nico Echavarria mid-swing; Scheffler confronted the fan and then conceded the hole. Four outlets covered the event, and they produced four meaningfully different stories from the same afternoon.
The Guardian put Trump in the headline. Nobody else did.
The Guardian's headline reads: 'Snedeker says Trump gets all the credit after US complete huge Presidents Cup comeback.' That is the only outlet in this group to surface the Trump angle at the top. The story notes Trump gave a speech before the final day and that Snedeker attributed the comeback, at least rhetorically, to that address. Whether Snedeker was being sincere or diplomatic is a question the coverage doesn't answer, but the Guardian is the only outlet that treated it as the lead fact rather than a footnote.
The NY Post ignored the scoreboard and found the better story
The NY Post ran nothing about the overall result in its headline. Instead: 'Scottie Scheffler confronts Nico Echavarria heckler at Presidents Cup — then delivers stunning act of sportsmanship.' The story describes Echavarria three-down through 13 holes when a fan shouted during his backswing on the par-4 14th. Scheffler confronted the heckler, then conceded the putt. It's a genuine sports moment, and the Post was alone in leading with it. The tradeoff is that a reader coming to the Post for the Presidents Cup result would have to dig for it.
The BBC and Yahoo gave you the result and not much else
The BBC's piece is a clean match report: 'US complete thrilling comeback to retain Presidents Cup,' with the 11th consecutive title noted. Yahoo Sports published a player records and results breakdown, useful as a reference but not a story. Neither outlet mentioned Trump, the Snedeker quote, or the Scheffler-Echavarria incident in their available excerpts. Both are doing exactly what a wire service does, which is fine, and exactly what this page is not.
What one side told you that the other didn't
Snedeker credited Trump. Three of four outlets didn't say so.
The Guardian headlined Snedeker's quote directly. The BBC called it a 'thrilling comeback' with no mention of Trump's pre-singles speech. Yahoo Sports ran a results table. The NY Post led with Scheffler. A sitting US president giving a locker-room speech before a major golf competition, then receiving public credit from the winning captain, is a specific, attributable news fact. It appeared in one headline out of four.
The Scheffler sportsmanship moment appeared in one outlet only.
The NY Post's account of Scheffler confronting a heckler and then conceding Echavarria's putt is a self-contained story with a named player, a named opponent, a specific hole (the 14th), and a specific match situation (Echavarria three-down through 13). None of the other three outlets mentioned it in their excerpts. It's the kind of detail that travels on social media and gets remembered after the scoreline is forgotten, and it lived exclusively at the Post.
What to watch
If Trump makes further public comments about the Presidents Cup win in the next 48 hours, watch whether the outlets that skipped the Snedeker quote on Sunday retroactively frame the story around him. A presidential statement would force the hand of outlets that buried the angle the first time.
See how outlets across the political spectrum framed this differently — and what each side left out.