Wake Forest's 42-0 halftime lead made the GameDay panel apologize on camera
Wake Forest beat SMU so badly that the story became the people who predicted otherwise. The Demon Deacons led 42-0 at halftime on the road, pushing their first-half scoring margin to 145-0 over their last four games, and the coverage split cleanly: CBS Sports asked whether Wake Forest belongs in the College Football Playoff; Fox News covered Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit posting a video apology for their pick. One story is about a team. The other is about television personalities. Both are real. Only one of them will matter in December.
Wake Forest upsets SMU; Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit apologize for wrong pick on College GameDay
3 sources · hover a dot to see coverage
What happened
Wake Forest defeated SMU on the road, leading 42-0 at halftime in what CBS Sports described as a rout. The margin extended the Demon Deacons' first-half scoring advantage to 145-0 across their last four games. On College GameDay, analysts Pat McAfee and Kirk Herbstreit had picked SMU; both posted a public apology video after the blowout. The win keeps Wake Forest in contention for a College Football Playoff berth. Coverage comes from three outlets, and the split between them is the most revealing thing about how the story traveled.
CBS Sports asked the playoff question; nobody else did
CBS Sports was the only outlet to treat the game as a CFP story, noting that Wake Forest's 145-0 first-half scoring margin over four games is the kind of number that makes selection committees pay attention. The piece framed the win as evidence that the Demon Deacons are ready to 'kick down the door' to the playoff. That framing requires treating Wake Forest as a legitimate contender, which neither of the other outlets bothered to do.
Fox News led with the apology video, not the score
Fox News covered the game entirely through the McAfee-Herbstreit apology, naming the 42-0 halftime deficit only as context for why two television personalities felt embarrassed. Wake Forest's actual performance, its playoff standing, and what the win means for the program did not appear. The story is structured around the GameDay segment, not the game.
What one side told you that the other didn't
One outlet ran the playoff angle. Two did not.
CBS Sports is the only source in this coverage that asked whether Wake Forest belongs in the College Football Playoff. Fox News and Newsweek covered the McAfee-Herbstreit apology. The apology is a one-day story. The playoff question is the one that will still matter in six weeks. A reader who only saw the Fox News piece learned that two analysts were wrong. A reader who only saw CBS Sports learned that a team might be building something.
145-0 in first halves over four games appeared once.
CBS Sports published the most specific number in the coverage: Wake Forest has outscored opponents 145-0 in the first half across their last four games. That figure doesn't appear in Fox News or Newsweek's coverage. It is the number that makes this game more than an upset, and it was reported by exactly one of the three outlets.
What to watch
Wake Forest's next game will test whether the playoff framing holds. If they win and CBS Sports' CFP angle gets picked up by ESPN or The Athletic, the apology-video framing will have been a one-week detour. If Wake Forest loses, the McAfee-Herbstreit story becomes the lasting frame for this game, which would be a strange outcome for a 42-0 halftime.
See how outlets across the political spectrum framed this differently — and what each side left out.